Skip to content
Search resources Open menu

Adult-CERT

Basics of Scientific Research

1. Accounting for True, Unproven and False Claims

This article explains discriminant validity in research on counterintuitive behavior by asking whether reported reactions distinguish true assaults from false or unproven claims. It uses diagnostic sensitivity and specificity to frame that limitation, then reviews military case-disposition data and research on false-report classification, emphasizing that unproven cases are not equivalent to false reports.

2. Symptoms are not Falsifiable

This short paper argues that proposed symptoms of counterintuitive behavior may be too broad to test scientifically because the same behaviors can occur in people who have not experienced sexual assault. It connects that concern to falsifiability under Daubert and questions whether research has adequately distinguished true, unfounded, and false reports when evaluating such claims.

3. Motivations for False Reports

This brief research summary describes categories of motives reported in studies of intentional false allegations, drawing on work by Kanin, a Bavarian police study, an FBI bulletin, and a later review. The listed categories include alibis, revenge, attention or sympathy, personal and relationship conflicts, and other circumstances, while the resource encourages case-specific examination of whether proposed explanations account for alternative motives.

4. Failure to Account for Confounding Variables

This resource examines factors that may complicate general claims about how a person behaves after sexual assault, including mental health, substance use, memory effects, and personal or cultural differences. It summarizes cited research and supplies questions for assessing whether an expert considered competing explanations, study populations, gender and orientation, and the possible effects of alcohol in the case at issue.

5. Confirmation Bias

This article explains how confirmation bias can shape an expert’s interpretation of a sexual assault allegation and cautions against treating counterintuitive behavior as proof that an assault occurred. It describes how studies relying on unblinded interviews and self-reports may overlook alternative explanations, then offers questions for examining whether researchers tested competing hypotheses and contradictory evidence.

6. Devil is in the Details

This article examines an expert’s testimony in a trial involving two male friends who remained friends after a single sexual encounter, and evaluates the four studies offered to support the opinion. It highlights mismatches between those studies and the case, including differences in participants, prior relationship, and circumstances, and recommends reviewing the full research and its limits before testimony.

Fit and Generalizability: Matching the Research to the Case

Snap Shot The question: Do the studies an expert cites describe people and circumstances like those in the case, and when does a mismatch matter? What fit requires: Under Daubert, Joiner, and amended Rule 702(d), each opinion must reflect a …

Juror Beliefs About Sexual Assault: What the Research Shows

Snap Shot The question: Do jurors hold mistaken beliefs about how people respond to sexual assault, and do those beliefs affect verdicts? What the research shows: In the one large survey of real jurors that I located (771 jurors in …

Reading Research Claims: A Guide for Attorneys

Snap Shot The question: How can an attorney, without training in statistics, test whether a research claim offered in court means what it is said to mean? What the research shows: Most misleading research claims are not fabricated. They come …

Sexual Assault Prevention Training and Court-Martial Members

Snap Shot The question: When court-martial members have received years of mandatory sexual assault prevention training, how does that training bear on voir dire, evidence, argument, instructions, and deliberations in a sexual assault trial? What the research shows: Meta-analyses of …