A Cure for a Non-Problem
This resource questions when expert testimony about counterintuitive behavior is needed and presents research on what jurors know about children’s memory, suggestibility, and responses to sexual abuse. It summarizes studies reporting both accurate public understanding and areas of misconception, then discusses how the evidence may inform admissibility debates and the limits of using general research to interpret an individual case.
Admissibility of Counterintuitive Behavior Testimony
Snap Shot The question: When may an expert tell jurors that behaviors such as freezing, delayed reporting, or continued contact are common after sexual assault, and when does that testimony become improper? What the research shows: Mock-juror research indicates that …
COUNTERING Counterintuitive Testimony (Adult, handout)
Often prosecution utilizes a counterintuitive “expert” to explain away problematic behaviors on the part of the complaining witness. Dr. Simpson offers a CLE training and 85-page handout on how to effectively challenge their expert.
- Seven specific strategies for cross
- A cure for a non-problem
- Accounting for true, unfounded, or false sexual assault claims
- Symptoms are not falsifiable
- Motivations for intentional false reporting
- Failure to account for confounding variables
- Confirmation bias
- The devil is in the details.
- Critique of:
- Freeze-Flight-Fight and Tonic Immobility
- Acting normal following the alleged assault
- Delayed disclosure
- Continued relationship with the accused
- Inconsistent, piecemeal, changing or incomplete memories
- Recantation
Mental-Health Records of Adult Complainants: What They Can and Cannot Show, and the Law of Access
Snap Shot The question: What can an adult complainant’s psychiatric diagnoses, treatment history, and clinical notes tell a court about an account of sexual assault, and when can a party obtain them? What the research shows: People with serious mental …
Overview of Daubert
This resource outlines the Daubert framework for evaluating scientific expert testimony, including the judge’s gatekeeping role and the requirements of relevance and reliability. It describes factors such as testability, peer review, error rates, standards, and general acceptance, then turns to Rule 702 and psychological testing concepts including validity and repeatability.
Preparing for and Examining a Counterintuitive Behavior Expert
Snap Shot The question: How can each side prepare for, present, and examine an expert on counterintuitive behavior so that the testimony stays within what the research supports? What the testimony can and cannot convey: Studies show that freezing, delayed …
Propensity Evidence in Adult Sexual Assault Cases
Snap Shot The question: When may evidence that the accused committed another sexual assault be used to show a propensity to commit the charged assault against an adult, and how much does such evidence prove? What the research shows: In …
The Neurobiology of Trauma in Court: What the Science Supports and Where Testimony Overreaches
Snap Shot The question: When a witness testifies that trauma “shuts down” the prefrontal cortex, floods the brain with stress hormones, or stores memories in fragments, how much is supported by research, and what can it say about a particular …
Victim Advocates, SARCs, and Victims’ Counsel: Privilege, Testimony, and the Earliest Disclosures
Snap Shot The question: What does research show about the effect of victim advocates on complainants, and what do the rules allow the parties to learn from, and about, advocates, sexual assault response coordinators (SARCs), and victims’ counsel? What the …
Vouching, Profile Evidence, and the Human Lie Detector Rule
Snap Shot The question: What may a witness say, directly or indirectly, about whether a complainant or an accused is telling the truth? What the research shows: People are poor lie detectors: in a meta-analysis of 206 studies, average accuracy …