Skip to content
Search resources Open menu

Child-CERT

In The Courtroom

A Cure for a Non-Problem

This resource questions when expert testimony about counterintuitive behavior is needed and presents research on what jurors know about children’s memory, suggestibility, and responses to sexual abuse. It summarizes studies reporting both accurate public understanding and areas of misconception, then discusses how the evidence may inform admissibility debates and the limits of using general research to interpret an individual case.

Arizona Victims’ Rights and Child Witnesses

Snap Shot The question: How do Arizona’s Victims’ Bill of Rights and parallel federal and military provisions shape what each side can learn from, and do with, a child complainant? What the research shows: In a prospective study, children who …

Confrontation, Child Hearsay, and Remote Testimony

Snap Shot The question: When may a child’s out-of-court statements be used at trial, and when may a child testify outside the defendant’s presence? What the research shows: Testifying is stressful for many children, and fear of facing the defendant …

Content-Based Credibility Assessment: CBCA and SVA

Snap Shot The question: Can the content of a child’s statement, scored with Criteria-Based Content Analysis (CBCA) or Statement Validity Analysis (SVA), show whether the account is based on experience? What the research shows: At the group level, accounts of …

Courtroom Accommodations for Child Witnesses

Snap Shot The question: Do accommodations such as support persons, facility dogs, child-appropriate oaths, and simplified questioning help child witnesses, and do they unfairly influence jurors? What the research shows: A simple promise to tell the truth reduced lying in …

Independent Psychological Examinations of Child Complainants

Snap Shot The question: When may a court order a child complainant to undergo a psychological examination by a defense-chosen or court-appointed expert, and what can such an examination show? What the research shows: An examination can assess characteristics that …

Motion to Preclude (Daubert)

This sample Arizona defense motion asks a superior court to exclude a prosecution expert’s proposed testimony under Evidence Rule 702 and requests a Daubert hearing. It argues that the opinions about counterintuitive behavior lack a sufficiently reliable scientific basis, raising concerns about testability, false-positive rates, and whether the underlying claims satisfy legal standards for expert evidence.

Other-Act and Propensity Evidence in Child Sexual Abuse Cases

Snap Shot The question: When may evidence of a defendant’s other sexual acts against children be used to show propensity, and how much does it prove? What the research shows: People with a history of sexual offending reoffend sexually at …

Preparing for and Crossing the Cold / CSA Expert

This resource combines a prosecutor’s training material on examining child sexual abuse and counterintuitive-behavior experts with guidance from prosecutor Susan Eazer on expert testimony. It reviews Arizona authorities on the scope of expert evidence and offers preparation, cross-examination, and closing-argument considerations, while emphasizing professional conduct and case-specific scrutiny of an expert’s methods and assumptions.

Taint Hearings and Child Witness Competency

Snap Shot The question: Is a child competent to testify, and can the way a child was questioned make the child’s statements or testimony too unreliable to admit? What the research shows: Abstract truth-lie questioning is a weak screen in …

The Newly Adopted Daubert Standard: Implications for Psychological Evaluations in Court

This 2012 State Bar of Arizona presentation explains how the Daubert standard and Arizona Rule of Evidence 702 may affect psychological evaluations and expert testimony in criminal cases. It outlines judicial gatekeeping and reliability considerations, then discusses forensic assessment methods, psychological testing, risk evaluation, and practical preparation and cross-examination of expert witnesses.

Vouching, Bolstering, and Profile Evidence

Snap Shot The question: Where is the line between permissible expert education and testimony that tells the factfinder whether a child is truthful, that abuse occurred, or that a defendant fits an abuser profile? What the rules bar: No witness …

What Jurors Understand About Child Witnesses

Snap Shot The question: What do jurors believe about how children remember, disclose, and behave when testifying, and do those beliefs match the research? What the research shows: Lay knowledge matches the research on some points and diverges on others, …