Skip to content
Search resources Open menu

Child-CERT

CSA Testimony Topics

A Cure for a Non-Problem

This resource questions when expert testimony about counterintuitive behavior is needed and presents research on what jurors know about children’s memory, suggestibility, and responses to sexual abuse. It summarizes studies reporting both accurate public understanding and areas of misconception, then discusses how the evidence may inform admissibility debates and the limits of using general research to interpret an individual case.

Age and Timing of Disclosure

This resource reviews research on how children’s age and other circumstances relate to whether and when they disclose sexual abuse, while framing the material as topics for evaluating expert testimony. It summarizes qualitative interviews and studies of disclosure timing, including the roles of developmental stage, relationships, abuse characteristics, and barriers to telling, and notes limits such as retrospective reports and sample composition.

Behavioral Indicators of Child Sex Abuse Victims

This summary addresses behavioral signs sometimes discussed in connection with child sexual abuse and cautions that no single symptom or symptom pattern identifies abuse. It notes that some children show no apparent behavioral change, while others may display varied emotional, behavioral, sleep, eating, or physical complaints.

Children’s Autobiographical Memory

This summary describes children’s autobiographical memory development and the distinction between general event scripts and memories of particular events. It states that young children may retain specific memories as well as general patterns, and that adults’ direct questions can help children retrieve and communicate remembered details.

COUNTERING Counterintuitive Testimony (Child, handout)

This State Bar of Arizona handout examines testimony about children’s responses and behavior in child sexual abuse cases. It surveys issues including disclosure timing, changing accounts, continued contact, interviewing practices, possible confounds, confirmation bias, and research relevant to evaluating competing explanations.

Criteria Based Content Analysis/Statement Validity Analysis

This short summary states that Criteria-Based Content Analysis and Statement Validity Analysis have not been shown, in the cited material, to reliably distinguish true from false reports by children. It identifies a 2005 reference and presents the point as part of a set of topics prepared for expert testimony.

Delayed Disclosure and Piecemeal Disclosure

This resource presents questions about delayed and piecemeal disclosure alongside summaries of research cited in a dissertation on children’s disclosures. It describes a qualitative study in which children reported concerns about consequences and disbelief, while also noting limited corroboration and possible influence from family members or therapists.

Difficulty with Identifying Dates of Abuse

This summary discusses why children and adults may have difficulty assigning dates or time frames to past events. It says time placement develops during childhood, dates may be peripheral rather than memorable details, and adults can help estimate timing by asking about contextual anchors such as residence or other people present.

Dissociation/Hyperarousal

The source distinguishes dissociation from hyperarousal as different responses discussed in relation to trauma. It describes dissociation as attention turning inward, with examples such as numbing or depersonalization, while hyperarousal involves heightened monitoring for possible threats.

Do molesters molest when others are in the room?

This resource contrasts a preliminary 1999 survey of offenders with a 2015 study of potential guardians and child sexual abuse severity. The former authors described their questionnaire as limited and unvalidated, while the later study reported that a nearby person was associated with reduced duration and lower likelihood of penetration.

Dr. Dutton’s recommended Forensic Interview Techniques

The source outlines a structured approach to interviewing children about possible abuse, beginning with rapport and narrative practice before asking about the concern. It recommends open-ended invitations, direct but non-leading follow-up questions when needed, and a neutral close, drawing on cited interview research.

Extended Forensic Evaluation When Sexual Abuse Is Suspected: A Multisite Field Study

This multisite study evaluates an extended forensic assessment model for children whose suspected-abuse cases may need more than one interview, using data from 147 participants across 12 states. The authors report credible disclosures in 44.5% of cases, abuse-unlikely findings in 19%, and unresolved outcomes in 36%, so the study does not identify all non-disclosures as false allegations.

Fight/Flight/Freeze

The resource reviews fight, flight, and freeze as possible responses to perceived danger, including tonic immobility and other passive reactions. It explains physiological stress responses and summarizes research proposing a broader sequence of defensive reactions, while noting that responses may vary with age and sex.

Gender and Disclosure

The source describes gender-related patterns that may shape how children disclose sexual abuse. It reports that boys may delay longer and worry about being seen as weak or homosexual, and it lists research citations addressing gender and disclosure.

Memory for Traumatic Events

This compilation reviews research on how trauma and stress can affect memory, including stability, recall, organization, and susceptibility to later information. Its cited studies describe varied findings, such as memory impairments or disorganization in some samples and vulnerability to misinformation, so it does not treat every traumatic memory as either uniformly accurate or uniformly impaired.

Piecemeal Disclosure

The compilation examines claims that children may disclose abuse in pieces or across repeated conversations, alongside concerns about changing or inconsistent accounts. It summarizes research describing disclosure as varied and sometimes prompted, indirect, withheld, or gradual, and includes critiques that question how these categories and supporting studies should be interpreted.

Process of Victimization or Perpetrators’ Process of Victimization

The resource presents a five-stage account of alleged perpetrators’ process of victimization, from selecting and engaging a child through grooming, assault, and concealment. It describes the cited research base and critiques how the five stages relate to earlier studies, including a small interview study that identified overlapping processes rather than a single pattern.

Reasons Children Delay Disclosure

The source summarizes reasons children may delay disclosing abuse, including limited understanding, fear of disbelief or family disruption, threats, shame, and loyalty to the alleged perpetrator. It also reviews a small qualitative study in which children described feared consequences and disclosure triggers, while noting limited corroboration and possible influence from adults around them.

Reasons Children Disclose Purposefully

Wendy Dutton’s short summary describes reasons children may purposefully disclose abuse, including seeking to stop it or obtain emotional support, and notes that some disclose after they feel safer. It lists research citations associated with the summary.

Recantation

This short resource discusses circumstances associated in cited literature with children recanting reports of abuse, including limited support and negative consequences after disclosure. It identifies research citations and is part of a February 2022 document titled “Areas of Inquiry and Summary for Expert Testimony and Supporting Research Citations.”

Script Memory

Wendy Dutton’s summary distinguishes script memory, concerning repeated-event patterns, from episodic memory for a particular event, and describes how schemas can shape attention and interpretation. It lists research on script memory, repeated events, and children’s reports, along with general primacy and recency principles.

Sexual Behavior in Abused and Non-abused Children

This brief resource says exploratory sexual behavior is common in young children and lists several behaviors it describes as more common among children with a history of sexual abuse. It cites Friedrich and colleagues (2001) and is attributed to a February 2022 research-citation document.

Stranger v. Intimate Abuse

This short summary states that children more often report sexual abuse by someone they know than by a stranger. It identifies research citations accompanying Wendy Dutton’s February 2022 summary.

The Null Hypotheses: Proven and Unfounded Claims of CSA

This resource presents an argument about how research on child sexual abuse allegations should distinguish substantiated, unsubstantiated, and false claims, and compiles studies and excerpts on those categories. It discusses difficulties in establishing ground truth and summarizes a multisite extended-evaluation study, including its unresolved cases and stated limitations.