Skip to content
Search resources Open menu

False Confessions

Models of Interrogation and Interview

1. The Interrogation Model (Reid Technique)

This compilation outlines the Reid interrogation approach, including its accusatorial steps and maximization and minimization tactics, then surveys criticism and research concerning coercion, confession reliability, and false confessions. It includes summaries of studies comparing accusatorial or persuasion-based methods with information-gathering or dialogue-based approaches, as well as discussion of recording, training, and juvenile suspects.

2. Deceptive Use of False Evidence

This resource discusses research on deceptive claims of evidence during interrogation and the role of perceived hopelessness in sexual-assault suspect interrogations, including discussion of polygraph or voice-stress claims. It also includes research abstracts on context reinstatement in interviews and contamination of crime details in confessions.

3. Selling Confession

This article describes interrogation strategies presented as encouraging suspects to confess by portraying the interrogator as an ally and suggesting confession may improve outcomes. It also summarizes research on how minimization and honesty themes can affect expectations about sentencing.

4. Confirmation Bias

This resource introduces confirmation bias and discusses how expectations can shape information gathering, interpretation, and interviewing. It compiles research examples and concludes with an article abstract connecting interrogation practices with prior evidence of guilt and the risk of false confessions.

5. Claims of Lie Detection

This resource summarizes research questioning the reliability of behavioral cues commonly treated as signs of deception, including gaze aversion, fidgeting, vocal features, and micro-expressions. It also notes limits of training and describes the evidentiary support discussed for behavioral-analysis approaches and neurolinguistic programming.

6. Pretext Phone Call

This article describes pretext phone calls used to elicit statements from suspects and compares callers’ tactics with police interrogation strategies. It discusses how apologies and other statements may be interpreted, alongside potential advantages, limitations, and references.

7. Investigative Interviewing (the PEACE model)

This resource describes investigative interviewing as an information-gathering approach and outlines the PEACE framework: planning and preparation, engaging and explaining, obtaining an account, closure, and evaluation. It also compiles research abstracts on memory-enhancing interviews, question style, interviewer bias, suspect interviews, and training in rapport-based methods.

8. Persuasive vs. Investigative Techniques

This compilation contrasts persuasion-based interrogation with investigative, dialogue-based approaches and summarizes research on confession outcomes, including laboratory studies of false confessions. It also describes the PEACE interview model and research on rapport, information gathering, and assessment of credibility.

Accusatorial Interrogation and the Reid Technique

Snap Shot The question: What does the Reid Technique, the best-known accusatorial interrogation method in North America, teach, what safeguards do its authors describe, and what does research show about its components? What the research shows: Laboratory studies with known …

False Evidence Ploys and Police Deception

Snap Shot The question: What happens when investigators tell a suspect that evidence exists that does not, or bluff about evidence that might exist, and how does the law treat deception in the interrogation room? What the research shows: False …

Investigative Interviewing and the PEACE Model

Snap Shot The question: What is the PEACE model of investigative interviewing, used by police in England and Wales since the early 1990s and adapted elsewhere, and what does the evidence show about how well it works with suspects? What …

Minimization, Maximization, and Implied Promises of Leniency

Snap Shot The question: How do minimization (sympathy, face-saving explanations, and downplaying the offense) and maximization (emphasizing the evidence and the seriousness of the situation) affect what suspects understand and whether they confess, and when does a theme become an …

Pretext Phone Calls and Recorded Confrontations

Snap Shot The question: When investigators arrange for a complainant, relative, or friend to call, message, or meet a suspect while the conversation is recorded, how should the resulting admissions, apologies, and denials be weighed, and what limits does the …

Sleep Deprivation, Fatigue, and Interrogation Length

Snap Shot The question: How do sleep loss, fatigue, time of day, and long or isolated questioning affect a suspect’s capacity to understand, decide, and resist pressure, and how do courts weigh these conditions when deciding whether a confession was …

Strategic Use of Evidence and Other Science-Based Interview Methods

Snap Shot The question: What are the Strategic Use of Evidence (SUE) technique and the related science-based interviewing methods promoted in the last fifteen years, including rapport-based questioning, the cognitive interview, cognitive credibility assessment, and the Scharff technique, and how …