Skip to content
Search resources Open menu

False Confessions

Forensic Evaluation of a Disputed Confession or Miranda Waiver

Published

Snap Shot

  • The question: What does a sound psychological evaluation of a disputed confession or Miranda waiver examine, and what can and cannot be concluded from it?
  • What the research shows: Professional guidance describes a multi-source evaluation: the recording and records of the interrogation, background records, interviews of the defendant and others, and standardized measures of Miranda comprehension, suggestibility and compliance, cognitive and language abilities, personality, and response style. Measures of Miranda comprehension relate strongly to age and intellectual ability, and forensic samples have produced norms similar to the original ones.
  • What it does not show: No test or evaluation can determine whether a confession is true or false or whether a waiver was legally valid. Evaluations are retrospective, usually conducted months after the interrogation, in an adversarial setting where effort and candor must be assessed, and the psychometric support for instruments used in court varies.
  • The law: Evaluation findings are offered under Fed. R. Evid. 702 (amended Dec. 1, 2023), Mil. R. Evid. 702, and Ariz. R. Evid. 702 (amended Jan. 1, 2024); courts decide waiver and voluntariness, and juries weigh reliability (Crane v. Kentucky). Arizona bars expert opinions on the truthfulness of a particular witness or of witnesses of a type, and on guilt or innocence (Lindsey, a child-victim case; Moran).
  • Issues for each side: For prosecutors, the research supports examining the evaluation’s data sources, timing, and effort testing; for defense counsel, presenting findings tied to the specific warnings and interrogation in the case rather than general claims of vulnerability.

When a confession or a Miranda waiver is challenged, one side or the court may ask a psychologist to evaluate the person who gave it. The questions vary. At a suppression hearing, the issue may be whether the suspect understood the warnings well enough to waive them knowingly and intelligently, or whether personal characteristics made the suspect unusually susceptible to the pressures used. At trial, the issue may be what weight the jury should give the statement. A psychological evaluation can describe abilities and characteristics relevant to those questions. It cannot answer the legal questions themselves, and it cannot say whether the confession is true.

This paper describes what a sound evaluation covers, for attorneys on both sides and for courts that appoint evaluators. It is not a protocol, and it does not reproduce the content, items, or scoring of any test; those materials are protected, and describing them would compromise their use. It summarizes the professional guidance and research on the components of an evaluation, the problems of timing and effort, and the limits on the opinions an evaluator may offer, and then the federal, military, and Arizona law on expert evidence of this kind.

The related research on the characteristics that an evaluation examines is covered in separate papers: Interrogative Suggestibility and Compliance, Miranda Warnings, Waiver, and Comprehension, and the papers on juveniles, intellectual disability, and mental illness in this hub.

The Questions an Evaluation Can Inform

Evaluations of disputed confessions usually address one or more of three questions. The first is capacity to waive Miranda rights: whether the person understood the words of the warnings, appreciated how the rights applied in his or her situation, and could reason about whether to waive them. The second concerns voluntariness: whether characteristics such as intellectual disability, youth, mental illness, intoxication, or fatigue bear on how the person responded to the circumstances of the interrogation. The third concerns reliability: whether characteristics such as suggestibility or compliance bear on the risk that the person accepted information or accusations from the interviewer (Goldstein et al., 2013; Kassin et al., 2025).

These are legal questions with psychological components. The court decides whether a waiver was valid and whether a statement was voluntary; the jury decides how much weight a confession deserves. The evaluator’s task is to describe the person’s relevant abilities and characteristics and how they relate to the specific warnings given and the specific interrogation that occurred (Goldstein et al., 2013; Rogers & Drogin, 2019). A finding that a person has a vulnerability is not a finding that the vulnerability operated in the interrogation, and a finding that a person has no unusual vulnerability does not establish that the statement was reliable.

Sources of Information

Professional guidance emphasizes that a forensic opinion rests on multiple sources of information, with attention to the reliability of each and to information that may contradict the evaluator’s working hypotheses (American Psychological Association, 2013). For a disputed confession, the most important source is usually the record of the interrogation itself. A complete recording allows the evaluator to see how the warnings were delivered, how the person responded, what was said before and after the waiver, and what tactics and information were introduced. Where only part of the interrogation was recorded, or none of it, the evaluator must rely on reports and testimony and should say so. Recording is discussed in Electronic Recording of Interrogations.

Other sources include the written waiver form and the exact wording of the warnings used; police reports and notes; school, medical, mental health, and correctional records created before the case; and interviews with family members, teachers, or others who know the person (Goldstein et al., 2013). Records created before the arrest are especially useful because they were not produced for the litigation. The exact warnings matter because Miranda warnings vary widely across jurisdictions; one analysis of 560 warnings found reading levels ranging from early elementary school to postgraduate (Rogers et al., 2007), so an evaluation of comprehension should be tied to the warning actually given.

The evaluator also interviews the person, covering background, the circumstances of the arrest and questioning as the person describes them, and his or her understanding of the rights. The person’s account of the interrogation is itself evidence to be weighed, not accepted at face value. Comparing that account with the recording can show where the two agree and where they diverge.

The Time Gap

Evaluations are almost always retrospective. A juvenile-evaluation chapter characterizes this work as, at heart, a reconstruction of capacity at an earlier time, often weeks or months before (Grisso & Riggs Romaine, 2013). The person’s current abilities are only a partial guide to his or her abilities on the day of the interrogation. Conditions that were present then, such as intoxication, withdrawal, sleep loss, or acute distress, may have resolved. Conversely, the person may have learned about the rights from counsel, other detainees, or the litigation itself, so that current comprehension overstates what he or she understood at the time. A sound evaluation acknowledges the gap, uses records from around the time of the interrogation to bridge it, and states how it limits the conclusions.

Standardized Measures

Several kinds of standardized measures are used, each answering a narrower question than the evaluation as a whole. Instruments for Miranda comprehension, including the Miranda Rights Comprehension Instruments developed from Grisso’s earlier work and the Standardized Assessment of Miranda Abilities developed by Rogers and colleagues, compare a person’s understanding and appreciation of rights with that of normative samples (Goldstein et al., 2003; Rogers & Drogin, 2019). In a forensic sample of 439 juveniles and adults referred for evaluation of Miranda waiver, results on the Grisso instruments were similar to the original norms and correlated strongly with IQ and age (Frumkin et al., 2012a). In a study of 55 delinquent boys, age, IQ, and special-education history were related to Miranda comprehension (Goldstein et al., 2003). Comprehension scores describe understanding under testing conditions; they do not by themselves establish what the person understood in the interrogation room.

Measures of interrogative suggestibility and compliance assess, respectively, the tendency to accept leading information or shift answers under negative feedback in a structured questioning task, and a self-reported tendency to go along with requests and avoid conflict. Gudjonsson (2013), who developed the most widely used scales, describes them as identifying vulnerabilities rather than assessing whether a confession is true, and cautions that translating a score into a conclusion about a legal question is the step most open to misuse. A U.S. forensic sample of 334 juveniles and adults produced results consistent with the British and Icelandic samples in the manual, with one component more related to cognitive variables and others more related to emotional and personality characteristics (Frumkin et al., 2012b).

Cognitive testing (intellectual functioning, memory, attention), language and reading measures, and personality and psychopathology inventories round out the picture when they are relevant to the referral question. Not every instrument is equally supported. A review of 364 assessment tools that forensic practitioners reported using found that nearly all had been empirically tested, but only about two-thirds were clearly generally accepted in the field and only about 40% had generally favorable reviews of their psychometric properties; legal challenges to such evidence were infrequent and succeeded about a third of the time (Neal et al., 2019). An international survey found that evaluators used structured tools in most evaluations and drew on a very wide variety of instruments (Neal & Grisso, 2014), which supports asking which measures were used and with what published support.

Effort, Candor, and Response Style

A person who is challenging a confession has an obvious reason to appear less capable or more suggestible than he or she is. Professional guidance therefore treats assessment of response style as part of the evaluation rather than an optional addition (American Psychological Association, 2013; Goldstein et al., 2013). Evaluators compare test performance with records created before the case, use measures designed to detect feigned impairment where appropriate, and look for patterns that do not fit known conditions. Feigning is not all-or-nothing: a finding of poor effort on some measures does not rule out genuine impairment, and a finding of adequate effort does not establish that every reported symptom is real (Goldstein et al., 2013).

Suggestibility measures present particular issues. The self-report compliance measure is transparent, so a high score may reflect how the person wishes to appear, and corroboration from records and informants is advised (Gudjonsson, 2013). In a small laboratory study, participants instructed to fake suggestibility raised some components of the scales but not others, and the authors proposed that an uneven pattern might help identify faking (Baxter & Bain, 2002). With 42 instructed volunteers, the pattern is a hypothesis, not a rule for defendants.

Hypothetical Example. Consider a hypothetical evaluation of a 24-year-old who confessed to an arson after a four-hour interrogation and now says he did not understand his rights. School records show average grades and no special education. On testing, his Miranda comprehension falls within the range of adults in the normative sample, his suggestibility scores are unremarkable, and his performance on two effort measures falls below levels typical of genuine impairment. The recording shows him paraphrasing the warnings accurately before signing. A sound report would state these findings plainly, including that they do not support the claimed lack of understanding, and would note that they still do not establish whether the confession was true. The example illustrates that an evaluation’s value to the court depends on reporting unfavorable findings as fully as favorable ones.

The Scope of the Opinion

Many researchers in this field consider that experts may testify about general research on interrogation and confession, including risk factors such as youth, intellectual impairment, and suggestible or compliant personalities. In a survey of 87 confession researchers (experts who publish or testify in the field, not psychologists generally), at least 80% agreed that those risk factors were reliable enough to present in court, and nearly all said their aim in testifying was to educate the jury (Kassin et al., 2018). The same survey showed that experts set a high standard before agreeing they would testify to a proposition. The 2025 scientific review likewise frames expert testimony as describing risk factors, not as determining whether a confession is false (Kassin et al., 2025).

An evaluator who examines the defendant adds case-specific information to that general research: findings about this person’s abilities and characteristics. Even then, professional guidance (Goldstein et al., 2013) and Arizona law on opinions about a particular witness’s truthfulness (State v. Lindsey, 1986, a child-victim case) point the same way: the evaluator should not offer an opinion that the confession is true or false or that the defendant was truthful. Rules in other jurisdictions and in courts-martial vary and should be checked. The evaluator describes; the factfinder decides. Experts are retained by one side in most cases, and writers in the field acknowledge that the adversarial setting can influence interpretation (Kassin, 2022). Professional guidelines call on forensic psychologists to strive for impartiality, to consider rival hypotheses, and to report findings that do not support the retaining party’s position (American Psychological Association, 2013). A court-appointed evaluator faces the same obligations, with reports typically available to both sides.

Limits of the Evidence

The instruments used in these evaluations were normed mainly on samples from particular countries, ages, and settings, and their norms may not fit every defendant; the forensic samples described above are reassuring but come from referred cases rather than random samples (Frumkin et al., 2012a, 2012b). Correlations between test scores and real-world false confessions are not well established, because the truth of confessions in referred cases is rarely known. Laboratory faking studies use volunteers given instructions, not defendants with real stakes. The time gap means that current findings are an imperfect proxy for functioning at the time of questioning.

Few of the key studies reported sex differences. The Goldstein et al. (2003) sample was all male, and the forensic samples in Frumkin et al. (2012a, 2012b) were not described in their abstracts by sex; most exonerated false confessors are men, and norms and findings drawn from mostly male samples may fit women less well. Group research can identify characteristics that raise risk; it cannot establish that a particular person’s waiver was invalid or that a particular confession is false.

Questions to Ask About This Research

When an evaluation is offered, ask what referral question it addressed, what records and recordings the evaluator reviewed, and whether pre-arrest records were obtained. Ask how long after the interrogation the evaluation took place and how the evaluator accounted for intervening learning or changes in condition. Ask which instruments were used, what normative samples they rely on, and whether those samples resemble the defendant in age, language, and setting. Ask how effort and response style were assessed and what the results were, and whether the report states findings that cut against the retaining party. These questions are explained in “Reading Research Claims: A Guide for Attorneys” on this site.

Evaluation of Confessions and the Law

Federal and Military Standards

Courts decide whether a waiver was knowing, intelligent, and voluntary and whether a confession was voluntary under the totality of the circumstances; the defendant’s characteristics are part of that inquiry, though under Colorado v. Connelly (1986) coercive police activity is a necessary predicate for finding a confession involuntary under the Due Process Clause. Once a confession is admitted, the defendant may present evidence about the circumstances in which it was obtained, because those circumstances bear on its credibility (Crane v. Kentucky, 1986). Expert evaluation evidence is offered under Fed. R. Evid. 702, as amended Dec. 1, 2023, which requires the proponent to show by a preponderance that the testimony is helpful, based on sufficient facts or data, the product of reliable methods, and a reliable application of those methods; Kumho Tire Co. v. Carmichael (1999) extends gatekeeping to all expert testimony. In United States v. Shay (1995), the First Circuit held that the district court erred under Rule 702 in excluding a psychiatrist’s testimony that a mental disorder bore on the reliability of the defendant’s self-incriminating statements, and remanded for the district court to decide the government’s fit and Rule 403 objections.

Evidence of this kind can be admissible. In United States v. Hall (1996), the Seventh Circuit vacated a conviction and remanded for a new trial after a district court excluded a proffered false-confession expert without applying the Daubert framework, and on retrial a jury again convicted the defendant (United States v. Hall, 1999); the case is described more fully in “Expert Testimony on Interrogations and False Confessions.”

In courts-martial, the defense may request expert assistance or an expert witness under R.C.M. 703(d)(2); for an expert witness the question is whether the testimony is relevant and necessary, and for a consultant whether the assistance is necessary for an adequate defense (Manual for Courts-Martial, 2024 ed.). Under United States v. Gonzalez (1994), the defense shows necessity by explaining why the expert is needed, what the expert would accomplish, and why defense counsel cannot gather and present the evidence without the expert. Admissibility is assessed under Mil. R. Evid. 702 and the factors in United States v. Houser (1993); the 2023 federal amendment to Rule 702 applies to the military rule from June 1, 2025, 18 months after its December 1, 2023 effective date, under Mil. R. Evid. 1102(a) unless the President acts otherwise (Joint Service Committee on Military Justice, 2025). Expert assistance and testimony in courts-martial are addressed further in “Confessions in Courts-Martial: Article 31(b), Mil. R. Evid. 304 and 305, and Expert Assistance.”

Arizona

Arizona applies Ariz. R. Evid. 702, which adopted the Daubert standard in 2012 and was amended effective Jan. 1, 2024 (Order R-23-0004). State v. Lindsey (1986), which concerned a prosecution expert on child victims, and State v. Moran (1986) permit an expert to describe general principles and research but not to give an opinion on the truthfulness of a particular witness or of witnesses of a type, or on guilt or innocence. In State v. Carlson (2015), the Arizona Supreme Court upheld the exclusion of an expert’s testimony relaying the defendant’s own claim that his confession to a television reporter was false, and of risk-factor testimony by an expert who had not examined the defendant and whose testimony went to a general propensity to lie rather than to mental or physical circumstances affecting the statement; the court did not hold that expert testimony on confession research is inadmissible. Under A.R.S. § 13-3988, the jury hears evidence bearing on voluntariness and gives the statement the weight it deserves. Arizona confession law is covered more fully in “Arizona Confession Law.”

Special Issues in Legal Practice

The research described above is the same whichever party relies on it. The science operates the same way regardless of who is asking the questions, and the research summarized here does not by itself favor either side. What differs between the parties is not the science but the vantage point — the particular places where these issues tend to surface, and the particular errors each party is best positioned to guard against. The two summaries below identify those recurring issues. They are offered for orientation, not as litigation strategy; in every case the controlling question is what the evidence in that case will, and will not, support, and the expert’s role is to inform the trier of fact rather than to advocate for either side.

Special Issues for Prosecutors

The research and professional guidance support asking specific questions about any evaluation offered against a confession: what records the evaluator reviewed, whether the recording was examined, how long after the interrogation the evaluation occurred, which instruments were used and with what published support, and how effort was assessed (American Psychological Association, 2013; Neal et al., 2019). Findings that the person paraphrased the warnings on the recording, functioned adequately in school or work, or performed poorly on effort measures are legitimate evidence, and a prosecution-retained or court-appointed evaluation conducted to the same standards may supply them. Arizona’s Lindsey rule and the general limits on expert opinions about truthfulness apply to every expert.

The research also counsels caution. Comprehension and suggestibility measures are reasonably well studied in forensic samples (Frumkin et al., 2012a, 2012b), and two federal courts of appeals vacated rulings excluding such testimony because the trial courts had not adequately analyzed admissibility (United States v. Hall, 1996; United States v. Shay, 1995); admissibility still depends on the particular opinion and the data supporting it. A finding of poor effort on some measures does not establish that a genuine impairment is absent (Goldstein et al., 2013). An evaluation reporting no unusual vulnerability addresses the person’s characteristics, not whether the statement is accurate, and it does not replace corroboration.

Special Issues for Defense

The research supports evaluations that tie findings to the case: the exact warnings given, the recording of the interrogation, records created before the arrest, and measures with published norms relevant to the defendant (Goldstein et al., 2013; Rogers et al., 2007). Evidence that a person’s comprehension, intellectual functioning, or suggestibility falls well outside typical ranges, documented across sources, is the kind of case-specific information the general research supports presenting, and Crane protects the defendant’s ability to put the circumstances of a confession before the jury. Defense counsel are often best positioned to obtain school, medical, and mental health records early and to secure the complete recording.

The research also counsels caution. An evaluation conducted long after the interrogation, without effort testing or pre-arrest records, is open to the objection that it measures the litigation rather than the interrogation. A vulnerability is not proof that the vulnerability operated, and an expert who would relay the defendant’s own claim of a false confession may be excluded (State v. Carlson, 2015). Retained evaluators who follow professional guidelines will report unfavorable findings, and counsel should expect that before commissioning an evaluation.

This paper is for educational purposes only and is not legal advice. The author is a psychologist, not an attorney; summaries of law are general and must be verified against current authority or with a licensed attorney.

References

American Psychological Association. (2013). Specialty guidelines for forensic psychology. American Psychologist, 68(1), 7–19. https://doi.org/10.1037/a0029889

Baxter, J. S., & Bain, S. A. (2002). Faking interrogative suggestibility: The truth machine. Legal and Criminological Psychology, 7(2), 219–225. https://doi.org/10.1348/135532502760274819

Frumkin, I. B., Lally, S. J., & Sexton, J. E. (2012a). The Grisso tests for assessing understanding and appreciation of Miranda warnings with a forensic sample. Behavioral Sciences & the Law, 30(6), 673–692. https://doi.org/10.1002/bsl.2018

Frumkin, I. B., Lally, S. J., & Sexton, J. E. (2012b). A United States forensic sample for the Gudjonsson Suggestibility Scales. Behavioral Sciences & the Law, 30(6), 749–763. https://doi.org/10.1002/bsl.2032

Goldstein, N. E. S., Condie, L. O., Kalbeitzer, R., Osman, D., & Geier, J. L. (2003). Juvenile offenders’ Miranda rights comprehension and self-reported likelihood of offering false confessions. Assessment, 10(4), 359–369. https://doi.org/10.1177/1073191103259535

Goldstein, N. E. S., Goldstein, A. M., Zelle, H., & Condie, L. O. (2013). Capacity to waive Miranda rights and the assessment of susceptibility to police coercion. In I. B. Weiner & R. K. Otto (Eds.), Handbook of psychology: Vol. 11. Forensic psychology (2nd ed.). Wiley. https://doi.org/10.1002/9781118133880.hop211017

Grisso, T., & Riggs Romaine, C. L. (2013). Forensic evaluation in delinquency cases. In I. B. Weiner & R. K. Otto (Eds.), Handbook of psychology: Vol. 11. Forensic psychology (2nd ed.). Wiley.

Gudjonsson, G. H. (2013). Interrogative suggestibility and compliance. In A. M. Ridley, F. Gabbert, & D. J. La Rooy (Eds.), Suggestibility in legal contexts: Psychological research and forensic implications (pp. 45–61). Wiley-Blackwell. https://doi.org/10.1002/9781118432907.ch3

Joint Service Committee on Military Justice. (2025). Amendments to the Military Rules of Evidence since 1984 (G. E. Maggs, Ed.; 2025 ed.). https://jsc.defense.gov/Portals/99/MRE%20Amendments%202025.pdf

Kassin, S. M. (2022). Duped: Why innocent people confess—and why we believe their confessions. Prometheus Books.

Kassin, S. M., Cleary, H. M. D., Gudjonsson, G. H., Leo, R. A., Meissner, C. A., Redlich, A. D., & Scherr, K. C. (2025). Police-induced confessions, 2.0: Risk factors and recommendations. Law and Human Behavior, 49(1), 7–53. https://doi.org/10.1037/lhb0000593

Kassin, S. M., Redlich, A. D., Alceste, F., & Luke, T. J. (2018). On the general acceptance of confessions research: Opinions of the scientific community. American Psychologist, 73(1), 63–80. https://doi.org/10.1037/amp0000141

Neal, T. M. S., & Grisso, T. (2014). Assessment practices and expert judgment methods in forensic psychology and psychiatry: An international snapshot. Criminal Justice and Behavior, 41(12), 1406–1421. https://doi.org/10.1177/0093854814548449

Neal, T. M. S., Slobogin, C., Saks, M. J., Faigman, D. L., & Geisinger, K. F. (2019). Psychological assessments in legal contexts: Are courts keeping “junk science” out of the courtroom? Psychological Science in the Public Interest, 20(3), 135–164. https://doi.org/10.1177/1529100619888860

Rogers, R., & Drogin, E. Y. (2019). Conducting Miranda evaluations: Applied and research foundations. Springer. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-13511-9

Rogers, R., Harrison, K. S., Shuman, D. W., Sewell, K. W., & Hazelwood, L. L. (2007). An analysis of Miranda warnings and waivers: Comprehension and coverage. Law and Human Behavior, 31(2), 177–192. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10979-006-9054-8

Legal Authorities

Colorado v. Connelly, 479 U.S. 157 (1986).

Crane v. Kentucky, 476 U.S. 683 (1986).

Kumho Tire Co. v. Carmichael, 526 U.S. 137 (1999).

State v. Carlson, 237 Ariz. 381, 351 P.3d 1079 (2015).

State v. Lindsey, 149 Ariz. 472, 720 P.2d 73 (1986).

State v. Moran, 151 Ariz. 378, 728 P.2d 248 (1986).

United States v. Gonzalez, 39 M.J. 459 (C.M.A. 1994).

United States v. Hall, 93 F.3d 1337 (7th Cir. 1996).

United States v. Hall, 165 F.3d 1095 (7th Cir. 1999).

United States v. Houser, 36 M.J. 392 (C.M.A. 1993).

United States v. Shay, 57 F.3d 126 (1st Cir. 1995).

Ariz. Rev. Stat. Ann. § 13-3988.

Fed. R. Evid. 702 (as amended Dec. 1, 2023).

Ariz. R. Evid. 702 (as amended effective Jan. 1, 2024, Order R-23-0004).

Manual for Courts-Martial, United States, R.C.M. 703(d) (2024 ed.).

Manual for Courts-Martial, United States, Mil. R. Evid. 702, 1102 (2024 ed.; Mil. R. Evid. 702 as amended 2025).

Related topic papers: Interrogative Suggestibility and Compliance · Miranda Warnings, Waiver, and Comprehension · Intellectual Disability and False Confessions · Juveniles and False Confessions · Expert Testimony on Interrogations and False Confessions · Voluntariness and Suppression of Confessions

Related topics from Arizona Forensic Services: Autism Online Offense · Courts-Martial