Affidavit for Acquiring an Expert on Alcohol Blackout / Amnesia
This sample declaration illustrates how a forensic psychologist might describe alcohol-related memory effects and related psychological concepts in a request for expert assistance. It discusses blackouts, reconstructive recall, source misattribution, suggestibility, and other possible influences, then applies them cautiously to a hypothetical case while noting the need to review case evidence.
Alcohol Blackouts in the Courtroom: Expert Testimony and Admissibility
Snap Shot The question: When may an expert testify about alcohol blackouts, what can such testimony reliably say, and where does it reach beyond the science? What the research shows: The core findings are well established: a blackout is a …
Alcohol-Involved Cases: Practice Issues for the Defense
Snap Shot The question: What does the research on alcohol, memory, and blackouts allow defense counsel to raise in an alcohol-involved case, and where does the same research counsel restraint? What the research shows: A blackout is a failure to …
Alcohol-Involved Cases: Practice Issues for the Prosecution
Snap Shot The question: What does the research on alcohol, memory, and blackouts allow prosecutors to present in an alcohol-involved case, and where does the same research counsel restraint? What the research shows: Memory gaps after heavy drinking are common …
Blackout as Criminal Defense or Mitigation
This 2013 evidence-based review evaluates scientific research cited when defendants claim alcohol-induced blackout as a criminal defense or mitigating factor. The authors report that studies do not provide an objective way to verify a blackout and argue that memory loss alone does not establish impairment of planning, attention, or other functions relevant to criminal intent.
Good Samaritan and Medical Amnesty Laws for Alcohol Emergencies
Snap Shot The question: What do Good Samaritan statutes, campus medical amnesty policies, and military safe-to-report and collateral-misconduct policies do when someone calls for help in an alcohol emergency or reports a sexual assault, what does the research show about …
Instructions for Voluntary Intoxication
This sample jury instruction tells jurors to consider voluntary intoxication when deciding whether the accused had a required specific intent, acted with premeditated design, or knew a relevant fact. It says blackout-related inability to remember is not itself a defense but may be considered in assessing intoxication, and that the prosecution must prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.
Intoxicated Suspects: Interviews, Miranda Waivers, and Confessions
Snap Shot The question: When a suspect is questioned while drunk, hung over, or in withdrawal, or later says he or she remembers nothing of the night or of the interview, what does the alcohol research say about the waiver, …
Intoxication and Consent: How Other Countries Define Capacity
Snap Shot The question: How do Canada, England and Wales, Victoria (Australia), Germany, Sweden, and Norway define consent and the incapacity that heavy drinking can cause, and what does the comparison mean for sexual assault cases tried under Arizona law …
Reconstructing a Blackout Period from Digital and Documentary Evidence
Snap Shot The question: When one or both parties do not remember part of an evening, how can messages, location data, receipts, video, and other records be used to reconstruct what happened, and what can such records not show? What …
The Goldilocks Challenge: Intoxicated Enough to Lose Memory, but Capable of Consent?
Snap Shot The question: In alcohol-involved sexual assault cases, how can a complainant have been intoxicated enough to have little or no memory of a sexual act and yet, on one view of the evidence, capable of consenting to it, …
Voluntary Intoxication, Blackout, and Criminal Responsibility
Snap Shot The question: When an accused was drinking heavily and reports no memory of the charged conduct, what does the blackout research say about voluntariness, intent, competency to stand trial, and sentencing, and how do military and Arizona law …